Ihtijaj (Argumentation) [Abu Mansur Ahmad Tabarsi, Saiyyed Amir Husayn Sarkishian] on *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. In the introduction. Al–Ihtijaj by Allama Abu Mansur Ahmad Tibrisi Vol Uploaded by Syed Naqvi. Islamic Urdu Book. Copyright: Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC). Download. Al-Tabarsi and the Distortion of the Qur’an. Al-Tabarsi mentions in his book al- Ihtijaj (vol. 1 pg. ) while discussing the argument of Amir al-Mu’minin `Ali radiya Llahu `anhu.
|Published (Last):||12 November 2008|
|PDF File Size:||3.72 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||10.70 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Naturally the Shi’ites make a distinction among the hadithsso that those transmitted from the Prophet are of greater authority, but nevertheless all traditions are listed together according to subject matter, not according to author. First ihgijaj tampered words of Yusuf by adding something, then we tampered altered, changed – name it as you wish his words by omitting one word from sentence.
This was Imam Khomeini’s view regarding his books pretty extreme I would saybut nevertheless, rabarsi scholars may have the opinion that his other works and efforts are to be appreciated.
Sign up for a new account in our community. Shaykh al-Saduq, the author of one of the four basic works on Shi’ite hadith s referred to above, compiled dozens of authoritative hadith collections, each of which usually follows a particular theme. There has certainly been for you in the Messenger of Allah an excellent pattern.
Or in the view of Tabarsi this verse been made up by companions? Look at what Imam Khomeini says about his works in his Anwar ul-Hidayah:. But Our scholars deny that. Perhaps one reason the Nahj albalaghah and the Shi’ite hadith literature in general have been neglected or simply branded as spurious is that ihyijaj very existence flatly contradicts the commonly accepted idea of a simple bedouin faith with few philosophical or metaphysical overtones. Didn’t know that, thank you brother!
As this verse has an apparent meaning and an esoteric meaning. Thus the very small number of the traditions that ihhtijaj imply otherwise should have proper interpretation. As for the “earth” in this location, it refers to the place of knowledge and life.
Majlisi collected his traditions from numerous earlier sources. After all, the Quran has been translated dozens of times. So basically, Noori didn’t simply wrote a book to prove ihrijaj Quran been tampered.
Allah said Tabars would protect His book. This belief in kufr. Man said Quran Holy book of Muslim nation been tampered, altered. Others who may feel that the present translation does not do justice to the literary qualities of the text may try their own hand at rendering it into English.
Go To Topic Listing. And in volume 10 of his book “adh-Dhariyah”, pageTahrani spoke about this answer of Noori. Are you asking my personal opinion?
This is not a very solid argument or even a proper comparison. You would accuse this scholar in nasb, kufr.
Ayatullah Muhammad Husayn Najafi and Sayyid Fadhlullah had many theological views regarding the Imams that were not mainstream, but no one labelled them disbelievers and outside the fold of Islam don’t start quoting attacks that have been done on these scholars, we are not talking about attacks and critiques, your point here is about disbelief and being deemed outside of the folds of Islam. As examples, we can mention a few of the works from which he derived the hadith s in the present collection, works which have been independently published in modern times.
First of all, it isn’t really clear to me what you mean by someone deeming the Imams as deficient? Al-Ihtijaj is one of the reliable books among Shi’a scholars. We are not playing games in kinder garden here, where people can delude each other.
Such man would be labeled like disbeliever by At the same time they refer to the era of terror and blood-shedding, which was tabqrsi out by the Safavids, as the golden era. The fourth work from which ‘Allamah Tabataba’i made his selections is Mafatih al-jinan ” Keys to the Gardens of Paradise “a standard collection of Shi’ite prayers compiled from Bihar al-anwar and other sources by ‘Abbas Qummi d.
Al-Ihtijaj In English? – Off-Topic –
Please don’t habarsi words games with me. This book is a reliance of great scholars and investigators even though much of the ahadith are Mursal ahadith. Could you please be short in answer.